Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Add Upworthy to your Google News feed.
Google News Button

There’s something undeniably magical about a marriage proposal. Whether it’s a dramatic public spectacle or an intimate moment between two people, it’s a gesture rooted in love, hope, and the promise of a future together. And for many, the engagement ring is a symbol of that future—something they’ll wear every single day of their lives.

That’s why when one woman turned to the internet to vent about the ring her fiancé gave her—a family heirloom she couldn’t stand—it sparked an intense debate.


The ring, affectionately dubbed the “Granny Ring” by the internet, once belonged to her fiancé’s grandmother. While heirlooms can be deeply meaningful, this one, well… was a tough sell.

"It looks like something you'd find in a museum commemorating those who drowned on the Titanic."

— Anonymous Reddit user

The woman admitted she tried to like the ring. She knew how much it meant to her fiancé, and she understood the layers of family history wrapped up in the gold and gemstones. But at the end of the day, it just didn’t feel right on her hand—and certainly not like something she wanted to wear for the rest of her life.

"Try as she might to like the ring, the bride-to-be didn’t love it."

— Anonymous Reddit user

She chose to post anonymously online, possibly because talking to her fiancé or anyone in his family felt impossible. Understandably so. In close-knit families, a conversation like that could spiral into drama or hurt feelings quickly. Still, the post went viral, and her fiancé might stumble across it anyway.

The internet reacts

The internet, as always, was quick to take sides. Some users saw her as ungrateful and shallow—unable to see past the aesthetics of a deeply personal gift. Others empathized with her dilemma, suggesting that honesty in a relationship is more important than pretending to love something that makes you uncomfortable.

trending.upworthy.com

One commenter put it bluntly: “If my partner gave me something I hated and expected me to wear it every day, I’d want them to know. It’s not about vanity, it’s about feeling seen.”

trending.upworthy.com

Others argued that a quiet conversation with her fiancé would’ve been better than airing the issue online. But again, it’s not always easy to navigate tricky emotional waters—especially when family and tradition are involved.

"People have personal styles to consider."

— Anonymous Reddit user

A not-so-happy beginning with a maybe-happy ending

In follow-up comments, some Reddit users claimed the couple eventually had a heart-to-heart and resolved the issue, perhaps finding a way to honor the grandmother's memory without sacrificing the bride-to-be’s comfort. That kind of compromise is the heartbeat of a healthy relationship—and maybe even a stronger foundation than the perfect diamond.

What’s clear is this: the story struck a nerve. It raised questions about tradition, taste, honesty, and the emotional weight we place on material objects. And maybe that's the bigger takeaway.

We all want to feel loved, understood, and accepted—especially by the person we’re planning to spend forever with. Whether that comes in the form of a family heirloom or a custom ring that reflects your style is a deeply personal decision. But being able to talk openly about those feelings? That’s priceless.

Would you wear a ring you hated?

Should sentiment always trump style when it comes to engagement rings? Or is it fair to want something that fits your own personal taste? Let us know—and if you’ve ever received a ring that didn’t quite hit the mark, we’re all ears.

More For You

A gay man in Vegas was approached by a 40-year-old stranger asking for advice on raising his son

A gay man in Vegas was approached by a 40-year-old stranger asking for advice on raising his son

Jack Remmington got a surprise he says he’ll never forget. While playing the slots in Las Vegas he and his friend were approached by a middle-aged man they had never met who wanted to know if they were gay. Although it was a relatively safe public space, you never know what might happen in a city fueled by alcohol, sex and gambling.

Source: GIPHY

Instead, the man who approached Remmington wanted to ask some perfectly wholesome advice about communicating with his young son whom he thinks is probably still in the closet. Remmington wrote about the interaction on his Twitter page and the breakdown has quickly gone viral for the best reasons. “Ok I just experienced the nicest exchange with a stranger and think it’ll help to share: I was playing on the Mariah Carey slots in Vegas (naturally) and a friendly circa-mid-40s ish guy sat down to play on the machine next to me,” Remmington wrote.

"I was sitting with @marcoalessifilm, both wearing pink (naturally) and after chatting a little to the guy about Vegas, he nervously asked if he could ask us a question. I knew where this was gonna go as it always does so did a bit of an inner eye roll but indulged him anyway."

"He then asked if we were together so we said no (we’re best friends and he has a fab bf) and he asked if we were gay, so we said yes. He then said he thinks his 13 year old son might be gay and wondered if he could ask us how best for him to navigate that."

"He lit up when talking about his son, and I nearly started crying at how much he clearly loved him. The guy wanted to know how to make his son feel most comfortable about himself whilst not being too overt and glaringly obvious in forcing a conversation about his sexuality."

Source: GIPHY

"This man is SO sweet. From rural Arkansas and said whilst things are so much better now, he still just wants the world to be totally equal for his son. Marco and I said he sounds like he’s doing all the right things and that making his son know he’s loved is the best he can do."

"We both gave a couple of anecdotes from personal experience, largely relating to condoning abstract things when you see them like normalising conversations around gay kisses on TV or calling our family conversations that might shame potential queerness."

"We also mentioned not accidentally policing things so as to shame him - for instance, often out of a sense of protection and love parents can frown on a child’s behaviour or outfit because they’re worried for their safety when on a night out etc."

Source: GIPHY

"But we stressed that if this was their feeling it’s important to vocalise this exactly, rather than leaving the child ruminating over the parent’s intentions and second guessing why they said what they said."

"So in terms of advice to friends or relatives of a potentially queer person, what would fellow queers advise is the best way to make it known they have their love and support without causing an uncomfortable conversation that might force someone to come out before they’re ready?"

You can read the whole thing on Remmington’s Twitter thread, here.

While it’s understandable that he and his friend were apprehensive about being approached, the exchange goes a long way toward showing we should never make too many hard assumptions about people based on their appearances alone.

Even in 2024, not every parent, child or friend has a safe space to educate themselves on LGBTQ issues.

Obviously, it would be ideal if this random guy had a friend, family member, or educator who could give him the advice he was looking for but we have to salute Remmington for being so generous and kind in his response. There’s so much we can learn from each other when we take the time to ask questions -- and listen.

Source: GIPHY

“My first impression was that he seemed nice as he chatted which is more than what tends to happen with people you sit next to in Vegas at the slots. That said, I didn’t expect it to take this turn at all,” Remmington said in an interview with Bored Panda.

“The relationship between him and his son has a 100% future – he was a wonderful and caring man, despite what he said was quite a difficult town to grow up in if you’re at all different. I wish all fathers could be like him.”

This article was originally published five years ago.

Keep ReadingShow less
Chris Hemsworth's response to his daughter's big question deserves applause

Chris explains what happened.

Image from ellentube/YouTube video.

Chris Hemsworth's response to his daughter's big question deserves applause

Chris Hemsworth might be best known for swinging a hammer as the Norse god of thunder in “Thor: Ragnarok,” but when it comes to being a dad, he’s just as legendary. The 35-year-old actor and father-of-three had a standout parenting moment that proves he’s more than just a superhero on screen.

It started with a curious question from his daughter

In a 2015 appearance on The Ellen DeGeneres Show, Hemsworth shared a story that starts with his daughter, 4-year-old India, having a very specific question about anatomy—and ends with a beautiful message about identity and acceptance.

Keep ReadingShow less

His old job wouldn’t stop texting him. So he charged them for every reply.

Leaving a job doesn’t always mean leaving it behind. One Redditor, u/antiworkthrowaway234, knew that all too well. After managing critical IT infrastructure for a company, they figured their exit wouldn’t stop the calls from coworkers needing help.

So they got ahead of it. “I was the only one who knew about tons of our IT infrastructure, and I anticipated that I was going to get tons of texts and phone calls from former coworkers,” they shared.

Keep ReadingShow less
School punishes girl for ‘unnatural’ hair color. Then she outsmarts them perfectly.
Representative photo by Canva

School punishes girl for ‘unnatural’ hair color. Then she outsmarts them perfectly.

Many schools enforce strict dress codes, but sometimes, those rules backfire spectacularly. When one private Christian high school told a student to dye her hair back to its natural color, they had no idea they were dealing with a genetic condition—or how perfectly she’d comply with their demand.

media1.tenor.com

Keep ReadingShow less