Skip to content
Search

Latest Stories

Add Upworthy to your Google News feed.
Google News Button

What does it mean to be truly intelligent? While IQ tests have long been used to measure cognitive ability, intelligence is often more about problem-solving and reasoning than test scores. A simple yet surprisingly effective way to assess logical thinking is the Cognitive Reflection Test (CRT)—a three-question challenge that has puzzled test-takers for years.

Representative Image Source: Pexels | Yan Krukov


Yale professor Shane Frederick introduced the CRT in a 2005 study published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives. Unlike traditional IQ tests, this one aims to determine whether a person relies on instinctive responses or engages in deeper analytical thinking. The questions appear straightforward, but their deceptive nature often leads to incorrect answers. Here they are:

  1. A bat and a ball together cost $1.10. The bat is $1.00 more expensive than the ball. How much does the ball cost?
  2. If five machines take five minutes to produce five widgets, how long would 100 machines take to make 100 widgets?
  3. A lake contains a patch of lily pads that doubles in size every day. If the lake is fully covered on day 48, when was it half-covered?

media.giphy.com

The test’s simplicity is what makes it so tricky. According to Frederick’s research, the correct answers are 5 cents, 5 minutes, and 47 days. However, many people instinctively arrive at the wrong conclusions, demonstrating the difference between quick intuition and deliberate reasoning.

A detailed breakdown of the answers shows why so many get them wrong. For the first question, a common mistake is assuming the ball costs 10 cents. That response seems logical at first glance but doesn't hold up mathematically. If the ball were 10 cents, the bat would be $1.10, making the total $1.20 instead of $1.10. Setting up an equation—x + (x + 1) = 1.10—solves for x = 0.05, meaning the ball costs 5 cents.

Giphy



"Despite the diversity of phenomena related to IQ, few have attempted to understand—or even describe—its influences on judgment and decision making."

— Shane Frederick

The second question follows a similar pattern of misinterpretation. Some test-takers assume that if 5 machines take 5 minutes, then 100 machines must take 100 minutes. In reality, productivity scales proportionally. If 5 machines make 5 widgets in 5 minutes, then 100 machines—working at the same rate—would still complete 100 widgets in 5 minutes.

Representative Image Source: Pexels | Pixabay

Perhaps the trickiest question of all is the lily pad problem. A frequent mistake is to assume the lake was half-covered at the halfway point—24 days. However, since the patch doubles each day, the correct answer is 47 days, because on the final day, the patch simply doubled from its previous size.

Giphy


The original study conducted by Frederick gathered responses from 3,428 participants across 35 studies over a span of 26 months. Many of the test-takers were university students from various institutions, receiving $8 to complete a 45-minute questionnaire. The test was designed to measure time preference and risk preference, revealing how people make decisions based on instinct versus analysis.


"System 1 thinkers respond spontaneously, often making mistakes, while System 2 thinkers engage in effortful thought processes."

— Shane Frederick

The test aligns with the research of Nobel Prize-winning psychologist Daniel Kahneman, who identified two modes of thinking. System 1 is fast and automatic, leading to quick but often incorrect answers. System 2 is slower, requiring effort and analysis, but producing more accurate results. Participants who immediately responded with 10 cents, 100 minutes, or 24 days were engaging in System 1 thinking, while those who paused to think through the logic correctly used System 2.

Giphy


Beyond just answering test questions, cognitive ability is linked to real-world outcomes. According to Frederick, individuals with strong cognitive skills tend to earn more, have better working memory, live longer, and react faster. While traditional IQ tests remain a benchmark for intelligence, the CRT offers a fascinating glimpse into how people process information and make decisions.

More For You

A cup full of chocolate kisses.

Chocolates are sweet, but this promposal might be sweeter.

Teen's braille promposal to blind girlfriend resurfaces, and it's still melting hearts

Prom season is often a time for creativity and big gestures, but one teen’s unique idea has raised the bar entirely. A promposal (prom + proposal) involving braille, chocolate, and a whole lot of thoughtfulness is making waves on social media years after it first happened. The story of Jake Schwartz and Paige Drury isn’t just a tale of young love—it’s a beautiful example of how a little extra effort can make someone feel truly valued.

In the video, Schwartz asks Drury to read a message he created using Hershey’s Kisses. As her fingers glide over the candies, she begins to spell it out, "Wait, that's a 'P'...'R'...'O'..." before realizing what it says and gasping with joy. She then happily accepts the invitation to prom, a moment that was met with applause from friends who were present.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pregnant mom asks for first-class seats, gets a reality check the internet couldn’t wait to deliver
Representative photo by Canva

Pregnant mom asks for first-class seats, gets a reality check the internet couldn’t wait to deliver

Flying with a young child isn't always smooth sailing, especially when it comes to seating arrangements. A soon-to-be mother, known online as Deekaytwo, found herself turning to the internet for advice after wondering if it was fair to ask front-row passengers to swap seats so she could sit with her toddler. But the reaction she got online was anything but supportive.

Representative Image Source: Pexels | Oleksandr P

Keep ReadingShow less
Images from a baby name reveal.

The moment this mom realized her daughter's name had a hidden Batman connection.

They picked the perfect baby name—until a movie changed everything

When it comes to baby names, parents pull inspiration from all sorts of places—family history, beloved books, even favorite meals. But sometimes, a name carries a hidden meaning that only one parent is in on. That’s exactly what happened to TikTok user @viashoe, whose daughter's name has a secret connection to Batman that she didn’t discover until well after the birth.

A casual Thanksgiving reveal

In a now-viral TikTok, @viashoe shared the moment the puzzle pieces fell into place. While spending Thanksgiving with her husband’s family, they decided to watch Batman: The Animated Series—a classic from the '90s that's known for its dark tone and emotionally complex characters. As the show played in the background, someone in the family was entertaining their baby girl when a familiar voice on the screen said, “My wife, Nora…”

Keep ReadingShow less
Manager forbids wage talk—employees hilariously post their salaries on company notice board
Representative image by Canva

Manager forbids wage talk—employees hilariously post their salaries on company notice board

Navigating corporate life isn't easy, especially when managers impose questionable rules on employees. A recent incident at a Planet Fitness in Kentucky highlighted how some managers misunderstand labor rights, particularly regarding salary discussions. Employees brilliantly confronted their manager after he attempted to forbid wage discussions—both at and outside the workplace.


Keep ReadingShow less
Identical twins separated at birth had dramatically different IQs in Korea and US
Representative photo by Canva

Identical twins separated at birth had dramatically different IQs in Korea and US

Twins typically fascinate us because of their incredible similarities. But sometimes, what makes identical twins truly intriguing are their surprising differences. A recent study in Science Direct highlighted exactly this, following the astonishing reunion of identical twin sisters separated as toddlers and raised in completely different cultures.


Keep ReadingShow less